Smart Siding Vs Hardie Board

Vinyl siding on a cape cod style home installed by siding windows group.

Smart siding vs hardie board.

In the early 90s our first team entered the ring. The top two engineered lap siding brands are the defending champion hardieplank fiber cement and the up and coming contender lp smartside engineered wood siding. Across the us smartside is about 25 35 cheaper than hardie. Hardieplank siding is the most popular and comes in a smooth finish or textured to mimic wood.

This difference amounts to thousands of dollars. Louisiana pacific lp smartside joined the ring seven years later and the fight was on. Lp is cheaper because both the materials and labor cost less than. James hardie fiber cement siding.

This australian based company is known for their fiber cement product hardie board. What are james hardie and lp smartside products made of. Us based lp smartside is notorious for their engineered wood that is moisture resistant. Hardipanel is vertical siding with a rustic board and batten appearance.

Both lp smartside and james hardie siding have their pros and cons. We ve all seen some epic battles over competing products in which parts of the ad campaign relied on going after the competition. For example the james hardie siding offers a greater range of styles to choose from can resist hail damage and you get a 30 year warranty. The survey also reports an average cost to value return average percentage of cost.

The aspyre collection includes lap siding made of extra thick boards for deeper shadows. Via upside to smartside this guide covers both products from all angles that matter to a homeowner looks durability cost of materials and installation and pros and cons of each option. Hardieshingle siding has the appearance of cedar shingles. Lp smartside in a battle for contractors builders and you this is a guest blog post by ryan carey of my 3 quotes.

In a remodeling contractor survey done by hanley wood the mid range vinyl siding cost for a typical home 1 250 sq. Move over hulk hogan it s time for the siding showdown. James hardie produces a variety of styles to fit many different tastes. Of siding installed in the us was about 14 300 according to the hanley wood remodeling costs report for 2020.

Let s begin with a basic analysis of james hardie products generally referred to as hardie or hardieplank james hardie products are often referred to as fiber cement products because of the materials that they are made out of the main bulk ingredient in james hardie siding products is silica dust. The primary difference between the materials used to make smartside siding and hardie siding is that smartside uses a wood based product while hardie uses a cement based product. Smartside this siding is coated with a smartguard solution a zinc borate phased process that adds strength to the product and helps to protect against pests and decay.